The Sacredness of Questioning Everything and Evolving in Monkey Town

Evolving in Monkey Town: How a Girl Who Knew All the Answers Learned to Ask the Questions
by Rachel Held Evans
Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2010.

Ed. Note: Since this review was published, Rachel Held Evans’ first book has been republished under the title of Faith Unraveled: How a Girl Who Knew All the Answers Learned to Ask Questions.

The Sacredness of Questioning Everything
by David Dark
Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2009.

Reviewed by Virginia Ramey Mollenkott

Evolving in Monkey Town book cover

Back in 1967, if anyone had told me that an evangelical publisher would release two excellent books about the central role of doubt and questioning in the faith-experience, I’d have felt a shot of hope and joy that was unknown to me when I was 35.

I had spent over a decade teaching in fundamentalist colleges, surrounded by a set of doctrinal “certainties” that dulled the wits and stifled the creativity of many of my students. In response, I wrote my first book, Adamant and Stone Chips: A Christian Humanist Approach to Knowledge. In it, I asked conservative Christians to turn away from their “apparent lack of the self-critical faculty, inevitably combined with an unpitying coldness toward human complexity, a total ignorance of ‘the delicate and subtle interplay of conscious and unconscious factors’ which make easy judgments impossible” (p. 98).

And now here I am, 44 years later and long since retired, rejoicing to hold in my hands two books by younger evangelicals arguing for the deepening of faith by facing all the doubts that may arise. Rachel Evans puts it this way: “Perhaps our love for the Bible should be measured not by how valiantly we fight to convince others of our interpretations, but by how diligently we work to preserve [protect?] a diversity of opinion” (p. 194). And David Dark writes, “The call to worshipfulness… is a summons to mindfulness in all I say and do, a mindfulness that requires… a questioning of everything” (p. 145).

Could it be that Christian humanism is awakening in the minds of younger evangelicals? If so, let it be, dear Lord, let it be! (Unfortunately, these publications may be due to the fact that Zondervan has recently become a subsidiary of HarperCollins Publishing Company). Whatever: these books by evangelicals are available, and are wonderful tools for awakening creative questioning in ourselves and others.

In case you didn’t know, Monkey Town is Dayton, Tennessee, the scene where in 1925 a teacher named John T. Scopes was tried for teaching Darwinian evolution in the public school. Defended by Clarence Darrow and prosecuted by William Jennings Bryan, Scopes was found guilty in what became known as the ultimate legal showdown between science and religion.

Now, 85 years later, a graduate of Bryan College in Dayton has written a book about her faith journey from a mind-set of blaming crime on the removal of prayer from the public schools and believing Clinton supporters would go to hell, to a determination to follow the liberating and loving teachings of “Jesus the radical rabbi” (p. 174).

Rachel Held Evans writes well, and Monkey Town is the quick-moving and compelling story of a thriving faith. She documents her “crippling lack of curiosity” and how she comes to realize that “doubt is the mechanism by which faith evolves” (pp. 218-19). She doesn’t know whether to call herself an inclusivist or a universalist or a particularist, but she agrees with what C.S. Lewis wrote in Mere Christianity: “We do know that no person can be saved except through Christ. We do not know that only those who know Him can be saved by Him” (quoted on p. 130). Those words got Rachel Evans through her sticking point, because (like me) she had found herself unable to love a God who would condemn to eternal Hell people who had been born into families or places where they would never hear a word about Jesus.

By contrast to Monkey Town’s fast pace and often humorous tone, David Dark’s The Sacredness of Questioning Everything is crammed with literary, cultural, and theological sophistication. One must read slowly in order to comprehend the many insights that come zooming through chapter after chapter about questioning: questioning first God, then Religion, then our Offendedness, Passions, the Media, Language, Interpretations, History, Governments, and the Future.

To try to hurry might be to miss some of the memorable phrases turned by a skilled stylist: “a fanatic is someone who can’t change his mind and won’t change the subject” (p. 50); television is “an electronic soul molester” given to “mind massage” (p. 70); “budgets are moral documents” (p. 191); “a religiosity of care, of lived reverence… is our only home and our only hope” (p 221); and “I believe in hope… in the cosmic recovery in which nothing will be lost and nothing will go unredeemed” (p. 185).

The Sacredness of Questioning Everything book cover

Since David Dark is such an adroit wordsmith, I was delighted that he insists on using the term evangelical in positive ways. (Old timers in EEWC will remember our drawn-out struggles about whether or not to drop evangelical from our title, since it has been associated with some truly disgraceful public policies.) Typical of Dark’s stance is the following: “I want to reposition the hot-button term evangelical as the ‘good news’ that questions all versions of the future, with an insistence on prioritizing conditions that sustain human life” (p. 227). And he goes on for pages about the “intentionally evangelical work of U2,” classifying Bono with Isaiah and Jesus as people “properly described as evangelical to bring good news to the poor” (p. 231). For David Dark, resurrection is “a moment in which human beings are reintroduced to each other across the gulf of mutual resentment and blame”—and for him, this is a “robust evangelical account of resurrection practice” (p. 215).

David Dark is scintillating in the way he brings pop culture and great art to bear upon the issues of life. I am haunted by his retelling of Ursula K. LeGuin’s short story called “The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas.” Omelas is a sovereign city-state where everyone is well fed and satisfied in a “beautifully well-balanced abundance.” But…upon coming of age, every citizen of Omelas is shown that underneath the grandeur of Omelas, there is one child kept alone in a dark windowless room, fed only with half a bowl of cornmeal daily and a jug of water. All the happiness of Omelas depends entirely on the misery of this one malnourished child living in lonely squalor. There is nothing anyone can do to change that fact because “freedom is messy” and “the price of one never-to-be-redeemed soul for the needs of the many is worth it.”

Some citizens of Omelas cannot bear this arrangement and walk away, out into the unknown darkness—but nobody knows where they go and their leaving does not help the child in any way. Furthermore, even as they walk away from Omelas, they are still wearing “the city’s fine clothes and comfortable shoes” (pp. 236-7).

Readers of CFT will of course recognize the “Omelesian economics of our own day,” the wealth of top-tier Americans oppressing the lower classes, and America’s wealth in general drawing resources away from desperately poor and powerless nations. How can we walk away? How can we not walk away? What good will it do to walk away? Having dropped all this into our consciences, Dark’s comment is simply that “The Lord’s Prayer posits an evangelical economics that is good news, first of all, for the least of these” (p. 238).

God help us to become genuinely evangelical, somehow finding ways to share the good basics of life with the least among our human relatives. A good beginning might be to read and share these books with people of every religion and no religion, whether living in Omelas or walking the road out of there.

© 2011 by Evangelical & Ecumenical Women’s Caucus. Originally published in the Summer (July-Sept.) 2011 year issue of Christian Feminism Today, Volume 35, number 2.

Virginia Ramey Mollenkott
Virginia Ramey Mollenkott (1932-2020) is the author or co-author of 13 books, including several on women and religion. She is a winner of the Lambda Literary Award (in 2002) and has published numerous essays on literary topics in various scholarly journals. In 1975, she spoke at the first national gathering of the Evangelical Women’s Caucus in Washington, D.C., and delivered plenary speeches at almost every gathering of the organization over the next 40 years. She has lectured widely on lesbian, gay, and bisexual rights and has also been active in the transgender cause. Mollenkott was married to Judith Suzannah Tilton until her death in 2018, and has one son and three granddaughters. She earned her B.A. from Bob Jones University, her M.A. from Temple University, and her Ph.D. from New York University. She received a Lifetime Achievement award from SAGE, Senior Action in a Gay Environment, a direct-service and advocacy group for seniors in New York City in 1999. In 2017 she was awarded the inaugural Mother Eagle Award. Even in her late 80s, Virginia Ramey Mollenkott continued to use her doctorate in English to share insights with folks who visit the EEWC and Mollenkott websites, and with elderly people in the Cedar Creek Community educational programs. She deeply regretted that her severe arthritis forbade her presence at the social justice protests during the Trump presidency.